Community Finance Fund for Social Entrepreneurs (CFFSE)

Report: Catalytic First-Loss Capital

The Community Finance Fund for Social Entrepreneurs (CFFSE) provides financial services for low-income populations in Australia.

Provider

Australian Government’s Social Enterprise Development and Investment Fund (SEDIF).

Recipient

Christian Super, a not-for-profit superannuation fund based in Sydney, Australia.

Amount and Instrument

AUD 4.5 million (or 37.5 percent of the total fund), provided as a grant.

Structure and Terms

The initial 37.5 percent capital protection is designed to diminish over time as more limited partners invest in the fund. In the first year, the CFLC will cover both interest and principal payments on any loan losses. After that it will cover only the principal component in any losses. If any of the CFLC pool still exists after 30 years, the fund manager can use this money at its discretion.

Motivations

Because this was a pioneering impact investment deal in Australia, both parties wanted to ensure the deal set a good example in terms of providing financial returns and social impact. The SEDIF grant improved the fund manager’s balance sheet, reducing the pressure to hunt for very high returns. From Christian Super’s perspective, the CFLC not only brought the opportunity in line with acceptable risk-return parameters, but SEDIF’s participation also brought some sector expertise, as the latter has been active in the field for some time.

Negotiations

Christian Super had done due diligence on the fund manager a few years prior on a similar proposal, but without the CFLC component. Ultimately they decided not to fund them because, though they were achieving positive social outcomes, they were financially not as robust. When the fund manager again approached them with the SEDIF grant program, which was specifically created to catalyze commercial capital toward addressing social issues, Christian Super worked with the two parties to create this transaction. To settle on the ratio of CFLC to its capital, Christian Super began by setting its target floor return and worked backwards to arrive at how much first-loss would be needed to feel secure and meet fiduciary requirements.

Highlights

INVESTEE DETAILS
Fund Manager	Foresters Community Finance
Inception Year	2011
Geographic Focus	Australia
Impact Focus	Provide investors with exposure to a diversified finance portfolio devoted to the social enterprise sector
AUM	AUD 12 million (USD 12.35 million)
Fund Capitalization	Grant and equity
Investment Period	Open
Investment Size	Varies
Target Return	RBA Cash Rate + 1.5%
Management Fees	1.4% fee, 0% carry
INVESTMENT APPROACH
Investment Instruments	Loans
Investment Period	3-5 years
Investment Size	Minimum AUD 20,000 (USD 20,700)
Track Record	AUD 2 million loaned across three transactions, as of the 14th August

Catalytic First-Loss Capital details the motivations, benefits, considerations and suitable scenarios behind the use of catalytic first-loss capital in impact investing transactions. Catalytic first-loss capital refers to socially- and environmentally-driven credit enhancement provided by an investor or grant-maker who agrees to bear first losses in an investment in order to catalyze the participation of co-investors that otherwise would not have entered the deal. Catalytic first-loss capital has gained recent prominence in impact investing dialogue as more investors look to enter the market.

Other case studies

GIIN Initiative For Institutional Impact Investment
- MN
  
  MN is a fiduciary asset manager that carries out the pensions administration for almost two million people in The Netherlands. MN has 129 billion euro assets under management and aims for both financial and social return and long-term value creation for its stakeholders, the large metal schemes PME and PMT, as well as the pension fund for the merchant navy. MN sees the integration of climate-related opportunities and risks in investment decisions and processes as its fiduciary duty. MN has engaged in impact investing since 2016. The current impact investments total 1.9 billion euro at the end of 2018. For more information, see www.mn.nl.
- Prudential Financial
  
  Prudential Financial, with operations in the U.S., Asia, Europe, and Latin America, provides its customers with a variety of products and services, including life insurance, annuities, retirement-related services, mutual funds, and investment management.
- The Salvation Army
  
  The Salvation Army is a registered charity that operates in 128 countries worldwide running charity shops, shelters for the homeless and coordinating disaster relief and humanitarian aid to developing countries.
Climate Investing Track
- SunFunder Beyond the Grid Fund
  
  Founded in 2012, SunFunder aims to drive a global energy transformation to provide universal access to energy and mitigate the environmental impacts of energy production and distribution to limit climate change.
- Energy Access Debt Fund
  
  responsAbility Investments AG is an asset manager in the field of development investments and offers professionally-managed investment solutions to private, institutional, and public investors.
Gender Lens Investing Initiative
- Glenmede
  
  Glenmede is an investment and private wealth management firm founded in 1956 with a long history of partnering with its clients to align their social and environmental goals with their financial objectives.
- Phatisa
  
  Phatisa is a Mauritius domiciled, sector-specific African private equity fund manager located in and operating across sub-Saharan Africa.
Report: Scaling the Use of Guarantees in U.S. Community Investing
- Healthy Neighborhoods Loan Pools I and II
  
  Healthy Neighborhoods promotes community revitalization through property acquisitions and renovations in distressed Baltimore neighborhoods.
- The Collaborative for Healthy Communities
  
  The Collaborative for Healthy Communities lends to federally qualified health centers, which provide healthcare to medically underserved communities.
- M-Pire Pilot and Green Rewards
  
  M-PIRE was a collaborative pilot between the New York City Energy Efficiency Corporation (NYCEEC) and Fannie Mae that helped Fannie Mae develop green mortgage products.
Report: Catalytic First-Loss Capital
- California FreshWorks Fund Term Debt Facility
  
  The California Endowment’s goal with the FreshWorks Fund is to increase the availability of healthy food options in areas where there is limited access, particularly low-income communities.
- Peak II (Providing Employment and Knowledge)
  
  Peak II engages in equipment finance lending in Tanzania.
- Democracy Prep Charter School
  
  Civic Builders aims to provide affordable charter school real estate, and it has done this by providing protection to more senior investors investing in dozens of schools nationwide.
Report: Lasting Impact: The Need for Responsible Exits
- Lok Capital's Exit from a Microfinance Company
  
  Lok Capital (“Lok”) is a private equity fund manager, founded in 2004, that focuses on fostering financial and social inclusion in India.
- Beartooth Capital's Exit from Montana Ranchland
  
  Founded in 2005, Beartooth Capital is a real assets investment firm that has acquired nearly 25,000 acres in the Western United States with the intent to restore and rehabilitate degraded wildlife habitats, waterways, and ranchlands.
- LeapFrog's Exit from Express Life
  
  LeapFrog Investments is a private equity firm founded in 2007 that invests in financial services and healthcare companies targeting underserved and low-income populations, primarily in Africa and Asia.
Report: Beyond Investment: The Power of Capacity-Building Support
- responsAbility Investments AG
  
  responsAbility, a Swiss asset manager, has been active in impact investing since 2003. Its aim is to drive the growth of development-related sectors—namely finance, agriculture, and energy—through return-seeking debt and equity investments.
- Medical Credit Fund
  
  The Medical Credit Fund (MCF), a nonprofit impact investment fund within the PharmAccess Group, provides loans in partnership with local financial institutions primarily to private health clinics and pharmacies across sub-Saharan Africa.
- Business Partners International
  
  Business Partners International (BPI) is a fund manager providing debt and equity financing to small and medium-sized enterprises in East and Southern Africa.

Stay Connected

Sign-up to receive our newsletter and announcements about the latest impact investing news, events, and GIINsights

Newsletter